Post Time: 2025-07-18
The world of blood sugar management and diabetes is filled with complex information and often, a dependence on single metrics. One of the most common is the Hemoglobin A1c test (HbA1c). While it's widely used as a gold standard for assessing long-term blood sugar control, Dr. Sam Robbins challenges its reliability, claiming it's far from the complete picture, and possibly misleading. Let's dive into why he argues HbA1c isn't the only truth about your glucose levels and what you should be aware of.
The Conventional Understanding of HbA1c
Before we critique, it’s essential to understand why HbA1c is so popular. This test measures the amount of glucose attached to hemoglobin, a protein in red blood cells. Since red blood cells have a lifespan of about three months, the test provides an average of your blood sugar levels over that period. A higher HbA1c indicates consistently higher blood glucose levels, which often point towards pre-diabetes or diabetes. Doctors use this metric to monitor how well someone's diabetes is being managed, and they set goals based on it.
| HbA1c Level | Interpretation |
|---|---|
| Below 5.7% | Normal |
| 5.7% - 6.4% | Pre-diabetes |
| 6.5% or higher | Diabetes |
Dr. Sam Robbins' Critique of HbA1c
Dr. Sam Robbins argues that the HbA1c isn't reliable, and certainly not the whole story. His main concerns revolve around the fact that HbA1c:
- Hides Blood Sugar Fluctuations: The HbA1c provides an average, thus masking significant fluctuations throughout the day. Someone might have a great HbA1c score but still be experiencing wild swings in blood glucose, with dangerous highs and lows. This is particularly true for people with brittle diabetes, and it's a critical weakness of the HbA1c that needs careful consideration.
- Ignores Glucose Variability: The risk from high blood sugar isn't just about average levels. Dr. Robbins emphasizes that wide variations (also called glucose variability) are detrimental to health. Rapid rises (spikes) in glucose after meals and similarly rapid falls put significant stress on your body and this isn't captured by the average nature of HbA1c test results.
- Is Affected by Individual Factors: Various factors can influence HbA1c readings without necessarily indicating true glucose levels. For example, certain anemias or other blood conditions, can falsely increase or decrease an HbA1c value, leading to inaccurate interpretations of one’s overall diabetic condition.
- Does not detect all types of glucose imbalances: The main purpose of HbA1c is to detect if glucose is bonding with red blood cells, meaning the test can miss conditions like Reactive Hypoglycemia where the blood sugar drops to very low levels that don’t leave a long term trace to measure from this test.
The Pitfalls of Relying Solely on HbA1c: Why It Might Be Misleading You
Relying solely on HbA1c for assessing your diabetes management can be misleading for several reasons, including:
The Masking of 'Roller Coaster' Blood Sugars
HbA1c can fail to reveal the "roller coaster" effect, where blood sugar levels fluctuate wildly throughout the day, spiking high after meals then plummeting to very low levels shortly after, or in between meals. These swings, called glucose variability, are extremely dangerous. They cause significant stress on the cardiovascular system, nerves, and other organs, but such fluctuations are hidden by an average-only measurement like HbA1c. The variability is a better predictor of future complications and disease than high or average blood glucose, making it critically important.
The Potential for Incorrect Diagnosis
As mentioned, various health conditions can impact HbA1c readings, irrespective of true blood sugar levels. If one is iron deficient or has a rare hemoglobin variant, they may present with an inaccurately high or low HbA1c value. This can lead to an incorrect diagnosis of diabetes when one isn't actually present, or a potentially dangerously misleading “normal” reading when an underlying condition exists, delaying treatment.
Ignoring Individual Variations
Everyone’s metabolism is slightly different and we handle glucose differently. What constitutes a "good" blood sugar level, or an acceptable variability can be dramatically different person to person based on numerous factors, not all of which are even known. Relying on general standardized ranges from a lab can cause those with better tolerance levels to develop medical anxiety, or the inverse case, people not aware of their poor glucose processing not realize they have high risk and diabetes.
Overlooked Postprandial Spikes
Postprandial spikes (the increase in blood sugar levels immediately after eating) are a significant cause of blood vessel damage and inflammation, but can be missed by the averaged nature of HbA1c tests. These spikes occur much more quickly than what an average number can register, and even with “normal” average values, the post-meal spiking could be causing significant and cumulative damage.
Lack of Responsiveness to Changes
HbA1c is a delayed-reaction measurement. Because the test only reports the average result from the past 2-3 months, it won't show immediate changes to your diet or lifestyle changes. This makes the HbA1c very impractical as a primary tool to monitor your progress when you are working on making positive lifestyle and dietary changes. It can take up to three months to see if a new approach is effective or not.
What Does Dr. Robbins Suggest? Practical Steps for Better Blood Sugar Management
Instead of relying solely on HbA1c, Dr. Robbins advocates for a more holistic approach to blood sugar management. Here are his recommendations:
1. Frequent Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose:
Use a continuous glucose monitor (CGM) or a standard glucose meter multiple times a day to capture a more complete picture of your blood sugar levels throughout the day. Measuring before and after meals, as well as when you exercise, will help identify hidden spikes and drops.
2. Focus on Glucose Variability:
Pay close attention to the differences between your lowest and highest blood sugar levels each day. Work with your doctor to try and reduce dramatic fluctuations by adjusting meals, timing and types of exercises, sleep routines, and stress. The goal is to smooth out blood glucose variations to a manageable and safer level.
3. Dietary Adjustments
Focus on whole, unprocessed foods with minimal sugars, including reducing refined carbohydrates (white bread, pasta, sugary snacks, etc), increasing whole food fiber, healthy fats (olive oil, avocado, nuts, etc), and proteins to slow down glucose release in the bloodstream.4. Personalized Treatment Approach:
What works for one person might not work for another. Collaborate with a healthcare provider who understands all aspects of glucose control beyond a simple HbA1c result.5. Regular Exercise:
Physical activity, particularly after meals, increases your body’s insulin sensitivity. This results in lower blood glucose, less variability, and better control over your glucose processing.6. Consider Other Markers:
Additional measurements, such as **fasting blood glucose, fructosamine, and lipid panel** testing can provide more insight into your glucose metabolism and its impacts on the rest of your body. Fructosamine, a less-known metric, is helpful because it measures glucose attached to other proteins in your blood over a period of 2-3 weeks, not just to hemoglobin, and can be helpful to compare to HbA1c results, or when your condition requires faster results.Conclusion:
While HbA1c is a widely used and valuable tool for evaluating diabetes management, it should not be the only metric you rely on, as Dr. Sam Robbins points out. The test's average-only result is not without significant shortcomings. A holistic approach that includes frequent self-monitoring, dietary adjustments, focus on glucose variability and personalized strategies should be considered in conjunction with the HbA1c test results for optimal blood sugar control. Your journey to managing diabetes effectively is better accomplished by an arsenal of information, and not by only relying on the HbA1c
By understanding the nuances of blood glucose regulation, including the limitations of HbA1c, you can work with healthcare professionals to make more informed decisions. It is crucial to look at your blood sugar levels as a dynamic process, not just an average. It's the daily consistency and reduced variability that matter most, and these cannot be captured by a single measurement like HbA1c.
With blooming trees and flowers, dust, mold and windy days, allergy and asthma symptoms increase. These symptoms and the medications used to treat them may lead to unexplained blood sugar changes. Join us in the GlucoseZone to learn how allergies and asthma impact your blood sugar levels. Learn how the sniffles, medications and stress of dealing with allergies and asthma affect your blood sugar levels and how to manage with the least. GlucoseZone™ is a digital therapeutic designed to help you reach your diabetes and exercise goals. Based on your real-time blood sugar levels, GlucoseZone provides you with individualized and tailored guidance, education, blood sugar level fat burning zone and support to help you meet a1c and blood sugar chart the exercise requirement of diabetes management. To see more content and start your FREE TRIAL. GlucoseZone® | Workouts For Diabetes Streamed Live & On-Demand: FACEBOOK: what to eat when blood sugar high INSTAGRAM: Twitter: #diabetesworkout #diabetesexercise #glucosezone #diabetes #diabetescure #fitness #exercise #workout #workoutvideo #type1diabetes #type2diabetes #bloodsugar #glucose #bloodglucose #diabetestreatment