BAD Science: Data Manipulation To Antagonize Keto [adb8d7]

2025-07-18

Post Time: 2025-07-18

Maintaining healthy blood sugar levels is crucial for overall well-being, and its impact extends far beyond just diabetes management. One area often overlooked is the relationship between blood glucose and bone density. While you might think of calcium and vitamin D when it comes to strong bones, the levels of sugar in your blood also play a significant role. Poorly managed blood sugar, particularly consistently high levels (hyperglycemia), can have detrimental effects on bone health, potentially increasing the risk of osteoporosis and fractures. This intricate link involves complex biochemical processes that affect both bone formation and bone breakdown. This article will explore this relationship and help you understand how maintaining stable blood sugar is also essential for optimal bone strength.

Factor Impact on Bone Density
High Blood Sugar Increases inflammation, impairs bone formation, and increases risk of fractures.
Low Blood Sugar May cause stress hormones to elevate, which over time can affect bone turnover.
Stable Blood Sugar Promotes healthier bone metabolism, reduces fracture risk and overall bone well-being.

The Biochemical Mechanisms Linking Hyperglycemia and Reduced Bone Density

The interplay between high blood glucose and compromised bone density isn't a simple one-to-one correlation; it involves a cascade of complex biochemical reactions. When your blood sugar remains consistently high, a condition known as hyperglycemia, it can trigger several processes that negatively impact bone health.

Firstly, prolonged hyperglycemia leads to increased inflammation throughout the body, and the bones are not spared from this impact. This chronic inflammation disrupts the delicate balance between osteoblasts (cells responsible for building new bone) and osteoclasts (cells responsible for breaking down old bone). This imbalance favors bone resorption over bone formation, gradually decreasing bone mass and density. The body's inflammatory response will take precedence, with the impact felt by areas like the bones where new cell growth occurs.

Secondly, high glucose levels can also interfere with the production of collagen, a crucial protein for bone structure. Collagen provides a framework on which minerals like calcium are deposited, giving bones their strength and flexibility. Poor collagen synthesis from increased blood sugar leaves the bone matrix weaker and more prone to fractures. It can also impair the body's natural healing process, making it harder for damaged bones to repair.

Thirdly, Advanced Glycation End-products (AGEs) are another issue. AGEs form when excess sugar molecules bind to proteins, lipids, and DNA, including those within the bone matrix. This can result in bone damage by hindering bone remodeling and weakening bone structure over time, increasing its fragility.

Finally, Hyperglycemia can alter the way your body utilizes key nutrients essential for bone health such as calcium, phosphorus and Vitamin D, disrupting bone metabolism. For example, the kidneys of individuals with prolonged hyperglycemia may excrete more calcium than is ideal, resulting in further loss of bone density.


Hypoglycemia and Its Lesser-Known Impact on Bone Health

While hyperglycemia has been extensively studied for its impact on bone health, the effects of hypoglycemia, or low blood sugar, are often overlooked. The relationship is not as direct, but repeated or severe bouts of hypoglycemia can lead to several issues that might indirectly influence bone density.

The body's stress response to low blood glucose can trigger a release of hormones like cortisol. While cortisol helps to raise blood sugar in the short term, chronic release due to frequent episodes of hypoglycemia can lead to bone breakdown over time. Elevated cortisol levels can inhibit the actions of osteoblasts which are essential for forming new bone mass.

Moreover, people with frequent or severe hypoglycemia may also experience related complications like falls, which can increase the risk of bone fractures. This does not diminish bone health but exposes bones to injury risks. For some people with diabetes, especially those with a history of repeated, low blood sugar reactions, there are more negative impacts on their cognitive health that can also increase their fall risk, again not reducing bone health but increasing its vulnerability to injury.

It's also important to note that managing hypoglycemia, which typically involves rapidly consuming glucose, can lead to dramatic swings in blood sugar levels. These fluctuations may also have an impact over time on overall metabolic health.

Hypoglycemia Impact Mechanisms Effect on Bones
Stress Response Release of cortisol Increased bone resorption
Increased Fall Risk Dizziness, confusion, loss of coordination. Higher likelihood of fractures, especially in elderly
Unstable Blood Sugar Rapid swings of high and low blood sugar Possible disruptions in bone metabolism

Practical Strategies to Stabilize Blood Sugar and Promote Bone Health

The good news is that adopting proactive strategies can improve blood sugar levels and, in turn, contribute to better bone health. Here's a practical guide for people aiming for healthier glucose and stronger bones:

  1. Prioritize a Balanced Diet: Focus on whole, unprocessed foods. Incorporate plenty of fruits, vegetables, and whole grains which are high in fiber and help regulate blood sugar. Reduce your intake of highly processed foods, refined carbohydrates (white bread, pasta, pastries), and sugary drinks as these cause rapid spikes in blood glucose, potentially leading to more inflammation.

  2. Regular Physical Activity: Aim for at least 150 minutes of moderate-intensity exercise or 75 minutes of high-intensity exercise per week. Strength-training exercises are particularly beneficial for bones, promoting bone mineral density, and moderate-intensity physical activity also increases insulin sensitivity helping the body regulate blood glucose more effectively.

  3. Weight Management: Maintaining a healthy weight reduces insulin resistance which also stabilizes blood glucose. Obese individuals typically have higher levels of inflammation, making bones vulnerable to damage, hence, maintaining a healthy weight helps both blood sugar and bone health.

  4. Monitor Your Blood Glucose: Regularly check your blood glucose levels. Understanding patterns of highs and lows empowers you to make adjustments to your diet and medication, optimizing your glycemic control, and subsequently improving bone health.

  5. Adequate Calcium and Vitamin D Intake: Ensure you’re getting the necessary vitamins and minerals critical for bone health by incorporating foods rich in calcium and Vitamin D. Consider supplementation under the supervision of a health professional if needed. If the body does not have adequate calcium from diet and it needs it, it will take from the bone. Vitamin D is necessary for calcium absorption so these go hand in hand.

  6. Regular Medical Check-ups: Work closely with your healthcare provider. Ensure they are aware of your blood glucose management goals, bone health status, and any family history of osteoporosis. A healthcare provider can adjust your treatment plans if required and can detect any changes early that can improve your long term outlook.

Strategy Benefit
Balanced Diet Regulates blood sugar, reduces inflammation, provides bone nutrients
Regular Exercise Increases insulin sensitivity, improves bone density
Weight Management Reduces insulin resistance, inflammation
Blood Glucose Monitoring Optimizes glycemic control, reduces high and low sugar fluctuations
Vitamin D & Calcium Supports strong and healthy bones
Medical Check-ups Enables personalized treatments, early detection

By taking these proactive steps you can manage your blood sugar levels more effectively, and significantly contribute to better long-term bone health, and mitigate the risks associated with hyperglycemia and hypoglycemia.

For more on LDL and ApoB, see these prior videos: - Cardiovascular Controversy: ApoB and All Cause Mortality - THIS is Why There is Confusion about Lean Mass Hyper-Responders with high LDL on Ketogenic Diets: - How to LOWER LDL on Keto. No meds! Supplemental Table 5 Lists Lipid Levels for the whole LCHF cohort of 2,034 participants. LDL-C levels were 3.71 mmol/l vs 3.62 mmol/l in the SD group. That’s a difference of 0.09, which can be converted to mg/dl by multiplying by 38.67. 0.09 * 38.67 = 3.48 mg/dl. Absolute mean levels of ApoB were 1.06 g/L and 1.03 g/L in the LCHF and SD groups, respectively. For interest - and because I know the question will arise - TG mean levels in the LCHF cohort were 133 mg/dl in the LCHF group and 137 mg/dl in the SD group. A point I do not make in the video regarding the JACC Advances paper, but that's worth considering, is that when they restrict analysis to subjects who completed at least 2 dietary questionnaires (Supplemental Table 7C), covering at least 2 days of eating (rather than 1), between group significance disappears, p = 0.34 (aHR CI: 0.49 - 8.14). This is likely due to decrease in power, but is nevertheless notable. intermittent fasting and blood sugar levels With respect to my comment on the macronutrient is 84 a good blood sugar level profile of a Burger King Whopper and Fries, Nutritionix lists the fasting blood sugar is 140 following macronutrient profile(s): Whopper: 680 kCal, 40g fat, 55g total carbohydrate, 4g fiber, 35g protein Medium Fries: 328 kCal, 15g fat, 45g total carbohydrate, 3.4g fiber, 3.8g protein Math: 55g fat * 9 Cal/g + 92.6g net carbohydrate*4 Cal/g + 38.8g protein*4 Cal/g = 495 Cal fr Fat + 370.4 Cal fr Carbs + Cal + 155.2 Cal fr Pro %Cal Carbs using Cal reported = 370.4 Cal / (1008 Cal) = 36.7% * using the Cal sum from macros, which can and usually do vary slightly, the denominator is adjusted to 1020.6 Cal, and the %Cal Carbs is 36.3% References Iatan I et al. Association of a Low-carbohydrate High-fat Diet with Plasma Lipid Levels and Cardiovascular Risk. JACC Advances. Siedelmann SB et al. Dietary carbohydrate intake and mortality: a prospective cohort study and meta-analysis. The Lancet Public Health. Kukuc L et al. Abstract 17808: Rapid Progression of CAD after stopping a statin and starting a ketogenic diet in a phenotypic lean mass hyper-responder. Circulation. Chapters 0:00 – Introduction 1:12 – JACC Advances Paper 8:48 – Keto Diet Shorten Lifespan 10:00 – LMHR with rapid Plaque Progression 13:33 – Conclusion
BAD Science: Data Manipulation to Antagonize Keto
BAD Science: Data Manipulation To Antagonize Keto [adb8d7]